I’m pretty much beyond the point of no return with regards to publishing with a big 5, or even being represented by an agent, (lol, unless my very outspokenness nets me one or the other, and yes, I’ve seen that happen, recently) so I think it’s safe enough for me to speak out about what so many of us are thinking and feeling.
There is a fuck ton of elitism and ableism within the glorified walls of traditional publishing and larger small press.
I’m not going to call out any one person (though I do have a few saved tweet threads about it).
Usually, it’s editors or agents (though I’ve seen authors say it too) who say things like:
“Keep trunking novels.”
“Write the next thing.”
You get my drift, right? If you’ve been around the publishing industry on twitter for a second you’ll have seen the types of threads and comments I’m talking about.
Authors and writers will talk about it privately (which kinda says something all by itself), but most won’t say boo about the publishing industry in public for fear they’ll lose their shot at publication.
Happened just last night.
Firstly. I say publishing has a problem with elitism, and it so does. It comes from all levels too, it comes from big 5 pub, agents, editors and agented/published authors (not all, of course).
The idea that you can *ONLY* be an author if you’ve pubbed with a big 5, or if you have an agent or if you can bootstrap yourself to write another book while one is out on query or submission. It’s so freaking elitist that I can’t even wrap my head around it.
There’s a helluva lot of elitism going on.
Secondly: It’s ABLEIST to say keep working, keep trying, write the next thing to people, especially marginalized people, many of whom have Mental Illness/Psychiatric Disorder. MANY writers do, so that very concept really needs to die by fire.
Not everyone is as open as I am about their mental illness… for stated reasons. They’re afraid they won’t get picked for publication/mentorship if it’s perceived that they can’t do the work due to mental illness. This fear is so common it’s mindboggling.
I did a thread about this last night, so I won’t repeat myself.
There have been panels and discussions at cons about why there is STILL so little diversity in fiction.
The answer has always been that the people who buy/produce/market books don’t resonate with diverse voices.
I hope to see change in the near future, so that new authors (or even, hell, salty old curmudgeonly authors like me) don’t have to fear not being picked because we speak out about problems we see or things we experience.
I won’t be holding my breath, though.
There’re are very valid reasons so many marginalized writers are self-pubbing or going with boutique presses.
It’s the only way we can get our stories out.
Another thread that may be of use to any of my marginalized readers.
Help me keep providing content, and you know, eating? Amazon Wishlist too.